Booking a fishing charter online: what to know before you pay
Most anglers find a charter through a booking site. FishingBooker is the biggest one, and plenty of people book through it with no trouble. But when a trip goes wrong, it's usually one of the same few things: the deposit, the weather call, or not being able to reach the captain.
I built Sportfish Hub's charter list to work a different way. Here's how the main sites handle money, refunds and contact, taken from their own pages, so you can pick what fits your trip.
How each site works
| FishingBooker | GetMyBoat | Captain Experiences | Sportfish Hub | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What you pay on top | Its help page says you pay the same as booking direct. Its terms allow a service fee "that may be charged." | Up to 13% plus a $20 service fee, per its terms | Not stated on the pages I read. You pay a deposit, then the rest on trip day | Nothing. I don't take payments |
| What the captain pays | A commission, typically 10-30% of the trip, per its terms | Not stated on the pages I read | Not stated on the pages I read | Nothing. Free to list |
| Who sets the cancellation rules | The captain's listed policy | The boat owner's listed policy | The site: credit outside the window, deposit kept inside it | You and the captain, agreed up front |
| Bad weather | Refund or reschedule, once the captain confirms it was unsafe | The owner or captain decides | Reschedule or credit for the deposit | You and the captain decide |
| Talk to the captain before you book | Yes, through its message button | Yes, through a booking inquiry | Not stated on the pages I read | Yes. Phone or Facebook, straight to the boat |
| Reviews | Trip reviews from its own bookings are marked as such. Others are checked by staff | Not stated on the pages I read | It calls them "100% Verified Reviews"; how isn't explained | No reviews on the site yet. Ask the captain where to read theirs |
Read from each site's own pages on November 19, 2026. Policies change, so check the listing before you pay.
The trade-off, plainly
A booking site holds your money. That's the main thing it gives you: if a captain cancels, the site handles the refund. That's worth something, especially in a place you've never fished.
Sportfish Hub doesn't hold your money. You deal with the captain, the same way people booked charters before the apps existed. You don't pay a booking fee, and the captain keeps the whole trip price. But any refund is between you and the captain, so settle the rules before you send a deposit.
What anglers run into
From fishing forums and review sites, the same problems come up again and again:
- The captain cancels late, or the boat's double-booked. It's the most common complaint in low-star reviews of the big booking sites.
- Deposit and refund fights. Usually over who decided the weather was bad.
- The boat or captain isn't the one in the listing. One angler on The Hull Truth booked a marlin trip in Cap Cana last December. The boat showed up more than an hour and a half late, with a different crew running it.
- No way to reach a person. Some reviewers say they couldn't get anyone on the phone when the trip went sideways.
- Extras on the day. Fuel, a longer run offshore, or a tip asked for that wasn't on the booking.
Questions to ask any captain before you pay
Whichever way you book, ask these first. A good captain answers them without a fuss.
- How much is the deposit, and when do I get it back?
- Who calls the weather, and by what time the night before?
- Will you be running the boat, or someone else? Which boat is it?
- What's included: bait, tackle, ice, fishing license, fish cleaning?
- What isn't included: fuel surcharge, a longer run, the mate's tip?
- What time do we leave the dock, and which dock?
Get the answers in a text or an email, so you both have them.
How Sportfish Hub works
- You find the boat by area or by the fish you're after.
- You see the boat, the trips and the rates the captain lists.
- You call or message the captain directly. Booking and payment happen between you and the captain.
- No booking fees for you. No commission for the captain. Free to list.